I’m going to go slightly off-topic today.
If you know me in person or have seen pictures of me somewhere, you know that I am not a twig. I’m curvy. I got back down to a size 6/8 (in pants, anyway – that myth about weight loss reducing one’s bra size is, in my experience, not true) once, but it was from nonstop stress (design school is not for the lazy), not eating enough, and having nonstop food poisoning when I did eat (ah, college cafeterias…). When I’m eating enough to sustain my (busy) activity level, I’m a 12 in dresses and a 10 in jeans. America Ferrera of “Ugly Betty” fame is actually smaller than I am (I base this on having seen the famous butterfly costume at close range – she’s close to a “standard” 8, which I’m sure of because design students learn to drape and make patterns on “standard” size 8 dress forms).
As you can imagine, it really chips my nail varnish when curvy women are slighted based on their size.
Last Saturday my best friend and I went to Pioneertown to see The Donnas (the show was fabulous, of course).
Bassist Maya Ford (aka Donna F) is nowhere near as thin as her bandmates. She’s zaftig enough to make me look almost skinny. Artwork for the band’s first three albums (American Teenage Rock and Roll Machine, Get Skintight, and The Donnas Turn 21) shows all four members, left to right, as equals. Which they are. I’ve been listening to The Donnas since high school and am quite sure the band would fall apart if they suddenly had trouble functioning as a quartet. Then came the band’s big-label debut, Spend the Night. The slumber-party-themed cover showed singer Brett Anderson in a short robe, drummer Torry Castellano in a tank top and long pajama bottoms, guitarist Allison Robertson (widely considered the band’s “hottest” member) posed flirtatiously in something short, slinky, and pink, and Maya in the back, in a frumpy brown checked pajama top. All you can see are her head, shoulders, and ample chest (since it’s okay to have a big chest as long as the rest of you looks rail thin). The implication is that she’s not as important.
Which is garbage, of course. The Donnas would not be the same without her. Maya is the resident bad girl who cracks the funniest jokes, writes many of the band’s sassiest lyrics, and probably parties the hardest (she supposedly made out with two male fans after one show because they were both very cute, and allegedly puts a certain herbal ingredient in her homemade rugelach – for the record, I don’t even drink coffee, but I have to admit the very idea of “special” rugelach is a little funny).
I know she was probably put in the background deliberately because I’ve encountered a few fat-phobic photographers myself. It’s annoying as hell. Given that the average American woman is currently a size 14 and my BMI was actually in the “normal” range when I was heavier, I don’t really qualify as “fat” in the first place.
On one such occasion, a local magazine oriented toward young men hosted a show at the House of Blues. One of my favorite local bands was playing, and my friend’s sister was in the magazine’s recently released calendar, so the three of us went, along with my friend’s then-boyfriend.
Of course, one of the magazine’s photographers had to get a picture of the hot calendar girl and her friends, and professional photographers can be very aggressive about dictating blocking and poses (especially when working for a publication with a narrow concept of beauty). My friend’s sister, a model whose “double feature” is not entirely natural, was front and center, with my friend (who is skinnier but has a smaller bust) pulled off to her right, her very tall boyfriend in the very back, and yours truly awkwardly positioned left and back. In the final picture, I could be seen only from the shoulders up and in shadow.
Honestly, this was insulting enough (especially since none of them would have even gone to the show if I hadn’t suggested it). What ticked me off a lot more was being photographed for some of the store’s early press coverage.
I’m well aware of the fact that fashion-oriented publications put the sticks front and center. As Alexis Meade snappily (and accurately) put it on “Ugly Betty” last season, “Models are hangers! Designers don’t want to see their clothes on fat hangers!” But I am NOT a professional model, and I should NOT be expected to resemble some toothpick from a Chanel ad.
Most of the people who have interviewed me have been perfectly professional. But when the time comes for pictures, they typically play around with different angles, trying to hide my non-arexic frame. Usually I’m photographed from the chest up. One magazine that has featured my flagship store does occasionally print pictures of store owners – IF they resemble the skinny models used in their fashion spreads. My semi-famous vegan Doc Martens were good enough to merit a photo, but I apparently wasn’t (the accompanying article was also full of mistakes and misquotes, but that’s another subject for another rant).
One glossy publication did show me in profile – in a fitted top that was hanging a bit loose at the time because I’d recently had my wisdom teeth removed and lost a few more pounds due to not being able to eat anything solid. Even then, they positioned me VERY carefully so my pelvis wouldn’t look wide. (My best friend is a gifted amateur photographer, so I know about little tricks like this.)
Am I hideous? Offhand, I’d say no. I’ve rejected marriage proposals. I’ve done some amateur modeling at friends’ requests (and, in a pinch, for my own ads). I was even offered a co-starring role in an independent film once (which I turned down because I have a business to run). My measurements do not make me ugly. Nor do they make me less of a person or preclude my ability to be as stylish as I want to be. Just as nobody should have to sacrifice style for ethics, nobody should be made to feel inadequate because they aren’t rail thin.
Some of the most powerful people who have worked in fashion are or were not beautiful. Diana Vreeland, for example, was pin thin (at a time when *some* curvature was preferred), had small eyes and a big nose, and had such oddly-shaped feet that all of her shoes had to be custom made. But, she knew how to make herself look interesting and is still widely respected as a style icon. How someone looks only matters when society allows it to matter. (Which isn’t to say that we shouldn’t groom ourselves and try to dress somewhat nicely. We can’t control our bone structure unless we resort to plastic surgery, but we can and should brush our teeth and polish our shoes.)
I am a fashionably curvy vegan. And there’s nothing wrong with that.